2009 Recap: Colby's solid season ranked as the second most surprising team performance in the NESCAC last year. Led by a stud FOGO in sophomore Craig Bunker and a two-headed monster at attack with Caddy Brooks (MVP of the all-Name team) and Whit McCarthy, the Mules managed to qualify for the NESCAC tournament. Their signature win came over Bowdoin in a 9-8 OT thriller. However, they struggled to compete with the other members of the NESCAC elite and suffered embarrassing losses to Conn and Bates, surprising results for a team that did an excellent job against mid-tier teams with wins over Trinity, Amherst and Williams.
2010 Trend: Stationary
What's hot: Any time you can win over 60% of your faceoffs, you have a chance to win any game. Craig Bunker is easily the most important player to this Colby squad as he always gives them a chance to respond after an opponent scores or to score again quickly after a Colby goal. Whit McCarthy returns, providing a proven scoring option to an offense that is going to be looking for someone to step up, especially through the midfield. McCarthy is not a complete player offensively and will have to show that he is a threat with both hands or defenses will have an easy time dealing with him. Of course, Coaching Jesus returns as well, providing the Mules with a strong hand at the helm.
What's not: An already sub-par defense loses its senior goalie. He wasn't a great stopper but did seem to do a solid job directing the defense, none of whom stood out individually. The same challenge of replacing an experienced goalie that many other NESCAC teams face is Colby's as well.However, the most damning loss is the graduation of Caddy Brooks. Whit McCarthy may have had the gaudy numbers last year but it was the gritty play of Brooks, dodging hard to the cage with both hands and absorbing checks then often dishing to McCarthy for either a time and space shot from the wing or a redodge. Without a two-headed monster at attack, Colby's offense will be more predictable.
What we should be talking about: Whether or not Thompson will walk on water at some point during the season; Who will be taking Caddy Brooks' spot on the all-Name team; The possibility that Colby was pretty average last year; Why so many Colby fans showed up on this forum in the past year; How important Craig Bunker is to this team
Monday, January 4, 2010
Trinity 2010
2009 Recap: Yes they were boring and ran at a pace that wouldn't scare a tortoise, but they only lost one game all year by more than three goals (Wesleyan). Still 2009 left something to be desired, especially with losses to Amherst and Colby and a first round exit from the NESCAC tournament at the hands of Bowdoin. Senior Graham Fadden was a pleasant surprise in goal, garnering second team all-NESCAC honors on a team that featured no defensive standouts. On offense, Trinity had the only offense that ran its plays through one player (Harper Cullen) more than Wesleyan did with Follansbee. Cullen did an admirable job shouldering a heavy load, gouging opposing teams despite an utter lack of other offensive talent with the exception of a few mediocre role players.
2010 Trend: Upward
What's hot: Harper Cullen is back and ready to make it rain more than Pacman Jones at a strip club. There is little mystery to the Trinity offense, prescribing iso after iso to Cullen. Unless Coach Finley managed to conjure up a decent sidekick for the third best offensive player in the NESCAC last year (after Stone and Hessler), I would expect more of the same strategy. This isn't necessarily a bad thing and given the weakened sate of Middlebury, Wesleyan and Williams, it could land Trinity in a position to make a surprise run for a NESCAC championship.
What's not: Losing Fadden after such a strong season hurts and it will most likely fall to sophomore Pete Johnson to fill those shoes. Johnson was a great high school goalie, but the transition to college lacrosse can be a challenge for gaolies in particular. Trinity had better hope he acclimated himself last year or else stall ball is going to fail miserably because they won't be able to keep opponents from capitalizing on a higher percentage of possessions. Trinity also needs to find someone to replace the very solid Connor Wells, whose proficiency at the X furthered the success of stall ball.
What we should be talking about: Who the hell is intimidated by a Bantam (or half the other NESCAC mascots for that matter); The fact that you better not walk outside the wrought-iron fences when visiting Trinity; The fact that the captain of the Trinity soccer team is an accomplished rapper; No seriously; And yes, he's white; Whether Harper Cullen ever gets mistaken for Cullen Harper
2010 Trend: Upward
What's hot: Harper Cullen is back and ready to make it rain more than Pacman Jones at a strip club. There is little mystery to the Trinity offense, prescribing iso after iso to Cullen. Unless Coach Finley managed to conjure up a decent sidekick for the third best offensive player in the NESCAC last year (after Stone and Hessler), I would expect more of the same strategy. This isn't necessarily a bad thing and given the weakened sate of Middlebury, Wesleyan and Williams, it could land Trinity in a position to make a surprise run for a NESCAC championship.
What's not: Losing Fadden after such a strong season hurts and it will most likely fall to sophomore Pete Johnson to fill those shoes. Johnson was a great high school goalie, but the transition to college lacrosse can be a challenge for gaolies in particular. Trinity had better hope he acclimated himself last year or else stall ball is going to fail miserably because they won't be able to keep opponents from capitalizing on a higher percentage of possessions. Trinity also needs to find someone to replace the very solid Connor Wells, whose proficiency at the X furthered the success of stall ball.
What we should be talking about: Who the hell is intimidated by a Bantam (or half the other NESCAC mascots for that matter); The fact that you better not walk outside the wrought-iron fences when visiting Trinity; The fact that the captain of the Trinity soccer team is an accomplished rapper; No seriously; And yes, he's white; Whether Harper Cullen ever gets mistaken for Cullen Harper
Williams 2010
2009 Recap: The beginning of 2009 boded very poorly for the Ephs, who dropped to 1-5 on five close losses to five very good teams. Then, in a serious case of "deja vu all over again," Williams mounted a furious run to the NESCAC tournament, punctuating the end of the regular season with defining wins over Bowdoin and Wesleyan before falling to Middlebury in the regular season finale in a reasonably close game. It seemed that for a second year in a row that this squad was peaking at just the right time. They even drew a favorable first round opponent in Wesleyan, who they had recently dispatched with relative ease 9-5. Alas, the Cardinals came out and exacted swift retribution in an 11-5 thumping that ended the Ephs' season on a sour note.
2010 Trend: Downward (Which is an understatement)
What's hot: They return a talented offensive midfielder in Matt Cranshaw who provided a strong complement to David Hawley last year and have some young attackmen like Sam Hargrove who contributed in supporting roles as freshmen. Second team all-NESCAC defenseman Andrew D'Ambrosio returns as well. Anddddddd....that's about it.
What's not: Gerbush? Graduated. Morrissey? Graduated. Hawley? Transferred. Williams isn't Middlebury in terms of roster depth. They can't just reload and replace three of the NESCAC's best (although Hawley was slightly overvalued by many) with the next iteration of recruits. Gerbush was a stud in cage (1st team all-NESCAC) and Morrissey was a freak athlete capable of completely dominating any game with his play on the wing, in transition and on the defensive end. Even Hawley, who struggled at times last year, was so instrumental to the Williams offense that any game plan for defending the Purple Cows centered on keeping the ball out of his stick lest he launch one of his signature 20 yard lasers past your goalie. Cranshaw is going to have to shoulder an extremely heavy load this year and it is definitely up in the air as to whether or not he is capable of doing it without other teams being forced to worry about Hawley first, second and third. Williams will be lucky to finish above 9th, and I fully expect them to make a play for the number one pick in the 2010 draft...wait...there's no reward for finishing in last? Crap, the Ephs are screwed.
What we should be talking about: How underrated of a color combo purple and yellow is, especially when paired with black; the 2011 season; Whether or not David Hawley will even get significant minutes at Brown; The fact that Williams is probably a better school than Brown by a smidge; How screwed the Ephs are; Who is going to be unfortunate enough to play goalie for this team because he's gonna see a lot of rubber
2010 Trend: Downward (Which is an understatement)
What's hot: They return a talented offensive midfielder in Matt Cranshaw who provided a strong complement to David Hawley last year and have some young attackmen like Sam Hargrove who contributed in supporting roles as freshmen. Second team all-NESCAC defenseman Andrew D'Ambrosio returns as well. Anddddddd....that's about it.
What's not: Gerbush? Graduated. Morrissey? Graduated. Hawley? Transferred. Williams isn't Middlebury in terms of roster depth. They can't just reload and replace three of the NESCAC's best (although Hawley was slightly overvalued by many) with the next iteration of recruits. Gerbush was a stud in cage (1st team all-NESCAC) and Morrissey was a freak athlete capable of completely dominating any game with his play on the wing, in transition and on the defensive end. Even Hawley, who struggled at times last year, was so instrumental to the Williams offense that any game plan for defending the Purple Cows centered on keeping the ball out of his stick lest he launch one of his signature 20 yard lasers past your goalie. Cranshaw is going to have to shoulder an extremely heavy load this year and it is definitely up in the air as to whether or not he is capable of doing it without other teams being forced to worry about Hawley first, second and third. Williams will be lucky to finish above 9th, and I fully expect them to make a play for the number one pick in the 2010 draft...wait...there's no reward for finishing in last? Crap, the Ephs are screwed.
What we should be talking about: How underrated of a color combo purple and yellow is, especially when paired with black; the 2011 season; Whether or not David Hawley will even get significant minutes at Brown; The fact that Williams is probably a better school than Brown by a smidge; How screwed the Ephs are; Who is going to be unfortunate enough to play goalie for this team because he's gonna see a lot of rubber
Bowdoin 2010
2009 Recap: Bowdoin circa 2009 was somewhat of an enigma. Playing one of the toughest schedules in the country, the Polar Bears registered a respectable 10-6 record en route to a semifinal loss to Tufts. This was a team that boasted two very talented midfielders in Kit Smith and Cullen Winkler, a solid attack and a strong defense led by Boomer Repko and Brian Holden. So what kept the Bears from greatness? Inconsistency in goal. Make no mistake about it, when he is on his game Jake McCampbell can be a stone wall. He posted six games with a save percentage of .650 or higher. Unfortunately for Bowdoin, he also posted six games with a save percentage of .550 or lower. Not by a coincidence, these were the six games that Bowdoin lost. Obviously, the difference in save percentage cannot be entirely attributed to McCampbell, but it is clear that he needs to greatly improve his consistency if Bowdoin is to compete with the offensive powerhouse that is Tufts.
2010 Trend: Upward
What's hot: Kit Smith is a force. He's big and powerful with decent speed and stick skills.. He has the potential to be dominant in a special way if he makes certain nuanced improvements to his game. The challenge in this is that Smith is also a hockey player which detracts from his preparation from lacrosse and will undoubtedly limit his impact. On the defensive end, when McCampbell is hot Bowdoin is in any game they play, no matter the opponent. Given the weakened states of Middlebury and Wesleyan this year relative to in the past, the skids are greased for Bowdoin to make a run for the NESCAC title.
What's not: Replacing Repko and Holden is a stiff challenge, further emphasizing the need for improved play from McCampbell. Kit Smith is going have to bear a heavy load on offense with the losses of Ashforth and Winkler. I have not seen Bowdoin's schedule yet, but if they have to run a gauntlet of tough games like last year they may be setting the bar too high. A more balanced schedule would be in order.
What we should be talking about: How ugly Bowdoin's horizontal black and white striped shorts were; What the hell Cullen Winkler's parents were thinking when they named him Cullen Winkler; Whether or not it's fair to declare that a new era is upon us if Tufts and Bowdoin meet in the NESCAC championship game; Does Jake McCampbell have multiple personality disorder?; Are there actually Polar bears in Maine?; If so, should visiting fans be worried?; Who would win in a fight between a polar bear and an elephant?
2010 Trend: Upward
What's hot: Kit Smith is a force. He's big and powerful with decent speed and stick skills.. He has the potential to be dominant in a special way if he makes certain nuanced improvements to his game. The challenge in this is that Smith is also a hockey player which detracts from his preparation from lacrosse and will undoubtedly limit his impact. On the defensive end, when McCampbell is hot Bowdoin is in any game they play, no matter the opponent. Given the weakened states of Middlebury and Wesleyan this year relative to in the past, the skids are greased for Bowdoin to make a run for the NESCAC title.
What's not: Replacing Repko and Holden is a stiff challenge, further emphasizing the need for improved play from McCampbell. Kit Smith is going have to bear a heavy load on offense with the losses of Ashforth and Winkler. I have not seen Bowdoin's schedule yet, but if they have to run a gauntlet of tough games like last year they may be setting the bar too high. A more balanced schedule would be in order.
What we should be talking about: How ugly Bowdoin's horizontal black and white striped shorts were; What the hell Cullen Winkler's parents were thinking when they named him Cullen Winkler; Whether or not it's fair to declare that a new era is upon us if Tufts and Bowdoin meet in the NESCAC championship game; Does Jake McCampbell have multiple personality disorder?; Are there actually Polar bears in Maine?; If so, should visiting fans be worried?; Who would win in a fight between a polar bear and an elephant?
Middlebury 2010
2009 Recap: A loaded offense. A solid faceoff guy. An underrated senior goalie with strong leadership qualities on the field. What was this team missing? Oh yeah, a defense. Oops. Close your eyes kids, this one got ugly. For the second year in a row, the perennial juggernaut that is the Middlebury lacrosse program fell flat on its face when it really mattered. There was no NESCAC championship for the Panthers, who lost despite having the single best player in DIII lacrosse whose uncanny ability to rip rope in the waning seconds of close games was put on display time and time again. Unfortunately for the Panthers, there were far too many of those close games including Bates, Amherst Trinity, Conn and Williams coming within three goals of beating them. Perhaps this is a testament to the depth of the NESCAC, but it seems to be more that Middlebury is slipping given the results of the past two years. They only won two NESCAC games convincingly all year, a 15-10 victory over Colby and their victory over Wesleyan in the NCAA tournament.
2010 Trend: Downward
What's hot: Certainly not the weather in Middlebury nor the expectations for this program. They have lost a TON on offense, which was the key to their degree of success last year. In lieu of rolling out Mike Stone and company to rain rubber down on opposing goalies, the Panthers are going to have to rely on a more balanced approach that incorporates a slower pace of play than in the past in order to give this young defense a chance to forge some kind of identity. Obviously, there is still a fair amount of talent in the program given the ease with which Middlebury can recruit. It's just that Middlebury needs to play things a little closer to the vest because of the combination of Middlebury's recent decline and the increased parity in the NESCAC. Which brings me to...
What's not: If I were a Middlebury alum, I'd be afraid, very afraid. Two years, two very talented teams, zero NESCAC championships. The bar is set so high for this program that this result cannot be construed as acceptable given the context. I have no beef with Dave Campbell, but he is fast-approaching a point where his job could and should be in jeopardy. Teams as talented as the past two Panther teams shouldn't have so many problems winning big games. What could happen with an even less talented team this year? I smell the potential for a disaster followed by Campbell being told to exit stage left. This is not a guarantee or even the most likely scenario, but something that has to be considered. In my opinion, Middlebury has reached a pivotal point in determining its role in the NESCAC and it seems like the Panthers are about to step back and become one of the ten teams in the NESCAC as opposed to being the singularly dominating force of past years.
What we should be talking about: Whether or not Coach Raba sent Coach Campbell a thank you card after winning the NESCAC championship; How freaking good Mike Stone was; The chances that David Hild scores an unassisted goal this year (I'd say about 1:100,000); How freaking good Mike Stone was; Is Pete Smith capable of carrying a heavy load on offense?; How freaking good Mike Stone was; How much Midd will miss Pete Britt; The impact of not being able to make Tom Petty jokes anymore; How freaking...oh you get the idea
2010 Trend: Downward
What's hot: Certainly not the weather in Middlebury nor the expectations for this program. They have lost a TON on offense, which was the key to their degree of success last year. In lieu of rolling out Mike Stone and company to rain rubber down on opposing goalies, the Panthers are going to have to rely on a more balanced approach that incorporates a slower pace of play than in the past in order to give this young defense a chance to forge some kind of identity. Obviously, there is still a fair amount of talent in the program given the ease with which Middlebury can recruit. It's just that Middlebury needs to play things a little closer to the vest because of the combination of Middlebury's recent decline and the increased parity in the NESCAC. Which brings me to...
What's not: If I were a Middlebury alum, I'd be afraid, very afraid. Two years, two very talented teams, zero NESCAC championships. The bar is set so high for this program that this result cannot be construed as acceptable given the context. I have no beef with Dave Campbell, but he is fast-approaching a point where his job could and should be in jeopardy. Teams as talented as the past two Panther teams shouldn't have so many problems winning big games. What could happen with an even less talented team this year? I smell the potential for a disaster followed by Campbell being told to exit stage left. This is not a guarantee or even the most likely scenario, but something that has to be considered. In my opinion, Middlebury has reached a pivotal point in determining its role in the NESCAC and it seems like the Panthers are about to step back and become one of the ten teams in the NESCAC as opposed to being the singularly dominating force of past years.
What we should be talking about: Whether or not Coach Raba sent Coach Campbell a thank you card after winning the NESCAC championship; How freaking good Mike Stone was; The chances that David Hild scores an unassisted goal this year (I'd say about 1:100,000); How freaking good Mike Stone was; Is Pete Smith capable of carrying a heavy load on offense?; How freaking good Mike Stone was; How much Midd will miss Pete Britt; The impact of not being able to make Tom Petty jokes anymore; How freaking...oh you get the idea
Tufts 2010
2009 Recap: After a modest 2008, the Jumbos exploded onto the scene in 2009 with the help of some serious production by D.J. Hessler, the only player even mentioned in the same breath as Mike Stone. While Hessler is fare more mortal than the now-graduated Stone, his talents paired with two ideal running mates at attack and very good team defense put the Jumbos in the NESCAC championship game where they lost to Wesleyan. Like the Cardinals, Tufts fell in the NCAA tournament in dissapointing fashion to a team (WNEC) that they had already beaten.
2010 Trend: Upward
What's hot: Upward? Didn't they finish in second? Oh that's right, the big honkin' elephants of Tufts University are my pick to take the 3rd Annual Dave Campbell Charity Giveaway featuring the men's lacrosse NESCAC championship. I suppose winning the NESCAC championship can be considered "hot." Yes, we all know they lost Harrigan, Yarboro, McNally and other important pieces, but they do return Ryan Molloy, the man who barely edged out Gabe Kelley for most underrated player in the NESCAC. The offense will be fine even with some depth issues through the midfield simply because Hessler really is that good. Tufts also has my absurdly early choice for NESCAC ROY, attackman Andrew Fiamengo, who has the ability to take some of the load off of Hessler. When two of your three (Wes, Midd, Bowdoin) major competitors for the NESCAC championship have serious holes at close defense, having a loaded attack will do a lot for you.
What's not: Harrigan was a solid goalie who can be replaced in terms of shot-stopping ability, but his intangibles such as leadership and communication will be sorely missed. The lack of a proven goalies only worries me when Tufts play Bowdoin and Conn, the only two teams that seem to be capable of legitimately slowing down the potent offense the Jumbos have assembled. A hot Jake McCampbell or Mark Moran (the two best goalies in the league when they are on their game) has the potential to stop any offense in its tracks. Without the ability to score a ton of goals, the potential is there for Tufts to lose because they won't be as stout defensively. However, such a concern is minor given that both Moran and McCampbell were wildly inconsistent last year.
What we should be talking about: The derogatory nature of the term Jumbo towards overweight elephants (Hey this is the NESCAC, where activism is in vogue); the impact of losing one of the best names in the NESCAC from their roster (Clem McNally); which substances influenced those who chose baby blue and brown as the school colors; whether it would be appropriate protocol or not to present Dave Campbell with an honorary NESCAC championship after Tufts wins in the spring; where to get D.J. Hessler's NESCAC POY trophies for the next two years inscribed.
2010 Trend: Upward
What's hot: Upward? Didn't they finish in second? Oh that's right, the big honkin' elephants of Tufts University are my pick to take the 3rd Annual Dave Campbell Charity Giveaway featuring the men's lacrosse NESCAC championship. I suppose winning the NESCAC championship can be considered "hot." Yes, we all know they lost Harrigan, Yarboro, McNally and other important pieces, but they do return Ryan Molloy, the man who barely edged out Gabe Kelley for most underrated player in the NESCAC. The offense will be fine even with some depth issues through the midfield simply because Hessler really is that good. Tufts also has my absurdly early choice for NESCAC ROY, attackman Andrew Fiamengo, who has the ability to take some of the load off of Hessler. When two of your three (Wes, Midd, Bowdoin) major competitors for the NESCAC championship have serious holes at close defense, having a loaded attack will do a lot for you.
What's not: Harrigan was a solid goalie who can be replaced in terms of shot-stopping ability, but his intangibles such as leadership and communication will be sorely missed. The lack of a proven goalies only worries me when Tufts play Bowdoin and Conn, the only two teams that seem to be capable of legitimately slowing down the potent offense the Jumbos have assembled. A hot Jake McCampbell or Mark Moran (the two best goalies in the league when they are on their game) has the potential to stop any offense in its tracks. Without the ability to score a ton of goals, the potential is there for Tufts to lose because they won't be as stout defensively. However, such a concern is minor given that both Moran and McCampbell were wildly inconsistent last year.
What we should be talking about: The derogatory nature of the term Jumbo towards overweight elephants (Hey this is the NESCAC, where activism is in vogue); the impact of losing one of the best names in the NESCAC from their roster (Clem McNally); which substances influenced those who chose baby blue and brown as the school colors; whether it would be appropriate protocol or not to present Dave Campbell with an honorary NESCAC championship after Tufts wins in the spring; where to get D.J. Hessler's NESCAC POY trophies for the next two years inscribed.
Wesleyan 2010
2009 Recap: This spring was a landmark season for the Cardinals. Although they eventually fell to Middlebury in the NCAA tournament, Wesleyan captured its first ever NESCAC championship. Even with only a decent keeper in Borerro, they were stout on defense, led by the best close defenseman in DIII, Spike Malangone. Offensively, it was all too often a one man show as nearly every possession went through Russ Follansbee when he was on the field. The methodical, plodding offense that was run served its purpose, but it often seem as Wesleyan failed to utilize some of their other offensive weapons.
2010 Trend: Downward
What's hot: Graduating Follansbee hurts, but it should allow for a bit more offensive diversity. Expect Killeen, Blumenthal and the younger Malangone to pick up some of the slack. Will Froats get some runs on O? Definitely an opportunity for a freshman or two to step up. In any case, a new look on offense could do Wesleyan some good. The Cards also do a little addition by subtraction with the graduation of Borerro, provided they can find someone who can at least replicate his results.
What's not: Unfortunately, not all losses are so kind. The only returning longpole is the LSM Gabe Kelley, probably the most underrated player in the NESCAC. Rebuilding a defense that predicates its success on cohesion and execution will be a major challenge for Coach Raba. Expect growing pains at both ends of the field.
What we should be talking about: How a team with such ugly uniforms (black jerseys and red helmets? BLEH!) won a NESCAC championship; Whether Wesleyan will beef up their 2010 schedule to give them a better shot at the tournament.
2010 Trend: Downward
What's hot: Graduating Follansbee hurts, but it should allow for a bit more offensive diversity. Expect Killeen, Blumenthal and the younger Malangone to pick up some of the slack. Will Froats get some runs on O? Definitely an opportunity for a freshman or two to step up. In any case, a new look on offense could do Wesleyan some good. The Cards also do a little addition by subtraction with the graduation of Borerro, provided they can find someone who can at least replicate his results.
What's not: Unfortunately, not all losses are so kind. The only returning longpole is the LSM Gabe Kelley, probably the most underrated player in the NESCAC. Rebuilding a defense that predicates its success on cohesion and execution will be a major challenge for Coach Raba. Expect growing pains at both ends of the field.
What we should be talking about: How a team with such ugly uniforms (black jerseys and red helmets? BLEH!) won a NESCAC championship; Whether Wesleyan will beef up their 2010 schedule to give them a better shot at the tournament.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)